A Case Study Exploring Whether Mediation Is Suitable
AI generated image
At 2Mediate, we support individuals and families across Reading, Maidenhead, Henley-on-Thames and the wider Thames Valley who are considering family mediation following separation. We understand that where a relationship has involved domestic abuse, controlling behaviour or concerns about personal safety, deciding whether mediation is appropriate can be particularly difficult.
This case study explores how a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (MIAM) can help someone consider their options following a difficult relationship, including whether family mediation is a safe and suitable way forward.
Considering family mediation following a difficult relationship
A father contacted 2Mediate to explore whether family mediation might be possible following a difficult relationship with his former partner, which had at times left him feeling anxious and unsettled.
During the relationship, matters had escalated to the point where he had contacted the police on more than one occasion because of concerns about the situation. The couple had been separated for two years, both had new partners, and circumstances were beginning to feel easier.
He wanted to find a way forward without going to court, which he felt could be traumatic for everyone involved. His priority was to find a constructive way to move forward with arrangements for their children.
What happens at a MIAM where there have been concerns about domestic abuse?
During his Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (MIAM), we explored his hopes and concerns, the existing arrangements for the children and what was working well or proving challenging.
He spoke positively about his former partner as a mother and wanted the children to enjoy consistent, safe and positive relationships with both parents, without being caught up in conflict.
We discussed the importance of keeping the children's needs at the centre of any decisions, allowing them to focus on their friendships, education and activities.
Given the children's ages, we also explored whether child-inclusive mediation might be appropriate. This can provide children with an opportunity to express their views and feelings in an appropriate setting, without making them responsible for decisions about their parents' arrangements.
Assessing whether family mediation is safe and appropriate
An important part of the MIAM was understanding his experiences during the relationship and whether any concerns remained.
He described having felt anxious and as though he was "walking on eggshells". We explored how these experiences had affected him, whether he continued to have concerns about his safety and wellbeing, and what support he had accessed since leaving the family home.
He described the positive difference support had made to his wellbeing over the previous six to twelve months.
Where there has been domestic abuse, family mediation requires careful individual assessment. The mediator needs to consider the nature and impact of the abuse, any ongoing risks, and whether each person would be able to participate freely, express their views and make decisions without fear, intimidation or pressure.
Mediation is not suitable in every situation, and the fact that a relationship has ended or circumstances have improved does not automatically mean it is appropriate.
Can family mediation take place where there has been domestic abuse?
We explored whether mediation might be possible and, if so, what arrangements could potentially help manage contact between the parents.
These included:
Shuttle mediation: where participants remain in separate rooms or locations and the mediator communicates between them, rather than the parents meeting face to face.
Separate arrival and departure times: to avoid participants having to meet at the mediation venue.
Clear communication arrangements: to establish appropriate boundaries and ground rules if mediation were considered suitable.
We explained that these arrangements are not guarantees of safety and would not necessarily make mediation appropriate. Any decision to proceed would depend on a thorough assessment of the individual circumstances, safeguarding considerations and whether both participants could engage freely and safely.
Deciding whether to proceed with mediation?
We also discussed the available funding options for family mediation and explained what financial support might be available, subject to eligibility.
At the end of the MIAM, the father decided to take some time to reflect on the options and speak with his counsellor before making a decision. We agreed that he could contact us when he felt ready to discuss potential next steps.
There was no pressure to make an immediate decision. The purpose of the MIAM was to help him understand his options and consider what was right for him and his family.
Family mediation, domestic abuse and putting safety first
Every family's circumstances are different. A MIAM provides an opportunity to discuss concerns, understand the mediation process and explore possible ways forward.
Where domestic abuse has been part of a relationship, safety must always come first. Careful assessment is essential before any decision is made about proceeding.
At 2Mediate, we provide family mediation and MIAM appointments for individuals and families across Reading, Maidenhead, Henley-on-Thames and the wider Thames Valley, helping people understand their options following separation.
If you are considering family mediation or need to understand your options for child arrangements following a difficult relationship, we can explain the process and help you consider whether mediation may be suitable for your circumstances.